Skip to main content
JustTheBeer

Intrinsic value vs price: how to read a buy-below price

A share price is what the market charges today. An intrinsic value (sometimes called fair value) is what a model says one share is worth, based on the company's own cash generation. The two are rarely the same, and the gap between them is what the Beer Score measures.

Each valued stock page turns that gap into two price levels, so you can see at a glance where the score would change band.

The two levels

  • Pure Beer below — the price at which the model value would cover at least 80% of the price (a Beer Score of 80 or more). It is the intrinsic value ÷ 0.80.
  • Good Pour below — the price at which the model value would cover at least 60% of the price (a Beer Score of 60 or more). It is the intrinsic value ÷ 0.60.

Both are rounded down to the cent. They are arithmetic on the published model value, nothing more.

A real example

Microsoft (MSFT), snapshot of 17 November 2026:

Intrinsic value (published model)$382.31
Reference price (16 Nov 2026)$517.99
Beer Score74 (Good Pour)
Pure Beer below$477.88
Good Pour below$637.18

The price of $517.99 sits between the two levels. That is why Microsoft shows as Good Pour: the price is under $637.18, but above $477.88, the level at which it would reach Pure Beer.

Why the levels sit above the intrinsic value

It can look odd that "Pure Beer below" ($477.88) is higher than the intrinsic value ($382.31). The reason is the 80% rule: a stock counts as Pure Beer when the model covers 80% of the price, not 100%. If you want the price at which the model covers the whole price, that is the intrinsic value itself: $382.31.

What moves the levels

  • A new filing changes the owner earnings or share count, so the intrinsic value and both levels move.
  • The price does not move the levels. It only moves where the price sits relative to them, and so the score.

What the levels are not

  • Not price targets. They do not predict that the price will reach them.
  • Not recommendations. They do not tell you to buy or sell at any price.
  • Only as good as one model. The model uses uniform assumptions (10% discount rate, 8% growth, 15× terminal multiple). If you believe a company deserves different assumptions, the sensitivity table on its page shows how the value changes; see How owner-earnings valuation works.

Growth priced in

The same page also shows the growth the current price implies. For Microsoft at $517.99, the model would need about 15.5% yearly growth for five years to justify the price, against the 8% it assumes. Reading the two together — how far the price is above a level, and how much growth the price needs — gives a fuller picture than either alone.

Where to go next

Educational research, not investment advice. Figures are from the published snapshot of 17 November 2026 and change daily.

More guides

Educational research, not investment advice. Worked figures are dated to the snapshot they name.